Creamy Potato Broccoli Bake

Featured in Perfect Companion Dishes.

Warm comfort with potatoes and broccoli mixed into a creamy, cheesy oven dish. Makes a chill meal for the family.
Rehan Magic House Recipes
Updated on Thu, 29 May 2025 14:53:56 GMT
Potato and broccoli baked under melted cheese in a white oven dish. Pin it
Potato and broccoli baked under melted cheese in a white oven dish. | magichouserecipes.com

My kitchen's filled with the smell of a true family favorite today: potato and broccoli casserole with an addictive creamy sauce. You just can't resist the mix of tender potatoes, crunchy broccoli, and that golden cheese crust on top. It's one of those meals that makes everyone at the table happy.

What makes it so extraordinary

What I really love about this casserole is how everything balances out perfectly. That creamy sauce, the crispy cheese top, and juicy veggies turn it into the ultimate comfort food. We put this on our table whenever the whole family gets together.

Ingredients you'll need

For my favorite casserole, I grab 800g potatoes and slice them thin, plus 300g fresh broccoli florets. I whip up the creamy sauce using milk, cream, a spoon of butter and flour. Plenty of shredded cheese and my go-to seasonings finish it off just right.

How to nail it every time

First I cut the potatoes into even slices and quickly blanch the broccoli to keep its nice color. The sauce gets super creamy when I cook the butter with flour and slowly stir in milk and cream bit by bit. Adding nutmeg, salt and pepper makes it irresistible. Then I layer everything in the dish, sprinkle loads of cheese on top and bake at 200 degrees until golden.

A baked dish with potatoes and broccoli topped with a rich cheesy sauce. Pin it
A baked dish with potatoes and broccoli topped with a rich cheesy sauce. | magichouserecipes.com

My personal twists

I love trying new things in my kitchen. Sometimes I swap in cauliflower instead of broccoli or add some fried chicken pieces. Using different cheeses like parmesan or spicy gouda gives the casserole totally new flavor notes every time.

What I serve with it

We usually enjoy this with a crisp salad or fresh baguette for soaking up the sauce. On lighter days I'll add some grilled veggies or a simple tomato soup on the side. There are endless ways to mix it up.

Smart make-ahead tip

What's really handy about this casserole: I can get it all ready and keep it in the fridge. When guests come over, I just pop it in the oven. This makes the evening way more relaxed for everyone.

Tasty and nutritious

This casserole isn't just super tasty but good for you too. The potatoes keep you full, the broccoli packs tons of vitamins, and the creamy sauce gives you needed energy. It's a well-rounded meal that brings together great taste and good health.

For the little food lovers

My kids can't get enough of this casserole, especially when I make it with their favorite veggies. I sometimes sneak in peas or carrots too. With mild cheese like mozzarella on top, it becomes a real kid-pleaser.

A potato and broccoli casserole with golden cheese topping, served in a white baking dish. Pin it
A potato and broccoli casserole with golden cheese topping, served in a white baking dish. | magichouserecipes.com

The lighter version

On days when I want something lighter, I make the sauce with low-fat milk and soy cream. Less cheese, more veggies, and the casserole turns into a low-calorie treat that still tastes amazing.

Smart leftovers usage

This casserole works great for using up leftovers. Whatever's in the fridge goes in – whether it's leftover veggies, cooked meat, or bits of different cheeses. This makes each casserole one-of-a-kind.

Super crunchy top

My secret trick for the perfect crust: I turn on the broiler for the last few minutes. The cheese top gets golden brown and super crunchy – it's so good. I stay nearby though, so nothing burns.

For big gatherings

When the whole family's coming over, I just make an XXL version. Double the ingredients, grab a bigger dish – done. The casserole handles multiple layers really well and keeps everyone full.

Veggie combo

I sometimes mix broccoli with cauliflower, which makes the casserole even more interesting. The different textures and flavors work together perfectly. That way everyone finds their favorite veggie.

A baked dish containing potatoes and broccoli shown in a white casserole dish. Pin it
A baked dish containing potatoes and broccoli shown in a white casserole dish. | magichouserecipes.com

Choosing your cheese

When it comes to cheese, I let my imagination run wild. Sharp cheddar, smooth gouda or strong parmesan – each kind brings its own character. I mostly like to mix different cheeses for the ultimate crust.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Is it ok to prep this bake early?
Yep, you can put it together ahead and pop it in the oven the next day. Leftovers warm up just fine too.
→ What kind of cheese melts the best?
Try Gouda or any easy-melting cheese. They give you that awesome, golden top.
→ Can I add more stuff?
Totally! For more protein, toss in chicken or ham if you like.

Creamy Potato Broccoli Bake

This laid-back bake mixes potatoes and broccoli in a smooth, cheesy sauce. Simple and a real winner for everyone at home.

Prep Time
15 Minutes
Cook Time
30 Minutes
Total Time
45 Minutes
By: Reham

Category: Side Dishes

Difficulty: Intermediate

Cuisine: German

Yield: 4-6 portions

Dietary: Vegetarian

Ingredients

01 A big handful of freshly grated cheese.
02 A generous splash of milk.
03 One heap of flour.
04 800g potatoes.
05 About 300g fresh broccoli.
06 A spoonful of butter.
07 A little cream.

Instructions

Step 01

After layering it all in your dish, throw loads of cheese on top, then bake at 200°C ’til it’s golden and bubbly.

Step 02

Toss in salt, pepper, and a bit of nutmeg to add loads of flavor.

Step 03

Start by gently melting butter with flour, then slowly add cream and milk while whisking. Keep going until you get a really smooth mix.

Step 04

Slice your potatoes into thin rounds and quickly dunk the broccoli in boiling water so it stays nice and green.

Notes

  1. Tastes amazing and is packed with good-for-you stuff.
  2. Potatoes fill you up for ages and broccoli’s full of vitamins.
  3. Go lighter by swapping in low-fat milk and soy cream if you want.

Tools You'll Need

  • Casserole dish.
  • Saucepan.

Nutrition Facts (Per Serving)

It is important to consider this information as approximate and not to use it as definitive health advice.
  • Calories: ~
  • Total Fat: ~
  • Total Carbohydrate: ~
  • Protein: ~