Pizza Grilled Cheese Delight

This Pizza Grilled Cheese has become my ultimate comfort food mashup, combining the stretchy cheese pull of a perfect grilled cheese with the savory flavors of pizza in every bite. The garlic butter exterior creates a crispy, aromatic crust that elevates this sandwich beyond ordinary.

I created this recipe during a rainy weekend when my kids were craving both pizza and grilled cheese. The compromise became their new favorite request, and honestly, I'm not complaining when they ask for it multiple times a week.

Ingredients

• Unsalted butter: Provides the perfect base for our flavored spread without adding extra salt
• Parmesan cheese: Adds a nutty depth to the butter mixture look for freshly grated for best flavor
• Garlic powder: Infuses the butter with aromatic flavor choose high quality for more intense flavor
• Italian seasoning: Creates that classic pizza herb profile featuring oregano basil and thyme
• White bread: Creates the perfect canvas with its mild flavor and good structure
• Mozzarella cheese: Essential for that authentic pizza stretch use whole milk mozzarella for best melt
• Pepperoni: Brings the classic pizza flavor opt for a higher quality brand for less grease
• Pizza sauce: For dipping best when slightly warmed to complement the hot sandwich

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prepare the garlic butter:

Combine very soft butter with parmesan cheese garlic powder and Italian seasoning in a medium bowl. Mix thoroughly until completely smooth and well blended. This flavored butter is what transforms an ordinary grilled cheese into something extraordinary with that pizza restaurant garlic bread flavor.

Butter the bread:

Generously spread the garlic butter mixture on one side of each bread slice ensuring complete coverage to the edges. Lay all buttered bread slices butter side up on a sheet tray until ready to assemble. The butter should be at room temperature for easy spreading without tearing the bread.

Begin sandwich assembly:

Heat a skillet over medium low heat. Place one slice of bread butter side down in the skillet. Layer with one slice of mozzarella followed by 6 pepperoni slices another slice of mozzarella 6 more pepperonis and a final mozzarella slice. This careful layering ensures even melting and pepperoni distribution in every bite.

Complete sandwich assembly:

Top with another slice of bread butter side facing up. The butter on both exterior sides will create that perfect golden crust while the layered interior ensures proper melting.

Cook to golden perfection:

Cover the skillet with a lid to trap heat and help the cheese melt evenly. Cook for approximately 3 to 5 minutes until the bottom bread achieves a beautiful golden brown color. Carefully flip the sandwich with a spatula keeping all contents inside. Replace the lid and cook the second side until similarly golden and the cheese is completely melted.

Serve immediately:

Plate the hot sandwiches with warm pizza sauce for dipping. The contrast between the crispy exterior and gooey interior is best enjoyed right away while the cheese is still stretchy.

Pin it

The garlic butter is absolutely the star ingredient in this recipe. I discovered its magic accidentally when I had leftover garlic bread spread in my refrigerator and decided to use it for grilled cheese instead of plain butter. The transformation was immediate and my family now refuses to eat regular grilled cheese.

Preventing Soggy Sandwiches

The key to maintaining crispiness lies in proper cooling. Place finished sandwiches on a wire rack over a baking sheet rather than directly on a plate. This allows air circulation underneath, preventing condensation from making the bottom soggy. The difference is remarkable especially if you need to make multiple sandwiches before serving.

Customization Options

This sandwich welcomes customization just like a regular pizza. Consider adding thinly sliced bell peppers, mushrooms, or olives between the cheese layers. For meat lovers, crispy bacon, ham, or Italian sausage work wonderfully. Just be careful not to overstuff, as this can prevent proper cheese melting and make flipping difficult. My family loves holding "pizza grilled cheese nights" where everyone creates their own custom combination.

Make-Ahead and Freezing

These sandwiches can be prepared ahead and frozen for quick meals. To freeze, assemble sandwiches but do not cook them. Place on a baking sheet and freeze until solid, then transfer to freezer bags. When ready to eat, cook from frozen in a skillet over lower heat and covered, adding a few extra minutes to ensure proper melting and heating throughout. This method has saved countless busy weeknights in our household.

Serving Suggestions

Transform this into a complete meal by pairing with a simple green salad dressed with Italian vinaigrette. For a more substantial dinner, serve alongside tomato soup for the ultimate comfort food experience. During summer months, we enjoy these with fresh vegetable sticks and additional pizza sauce for dipping. The combination of warm sandwich and cool vegetables creates a satisfying contrast.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use a different type of bread?

Yes, you can substitute with sourdough, whole wheat, or any other bread you prefer. Just make sure it's sturdy enough to hold the layers.

→ What other cheeses work well?

While mozzarella is classic, you can try provolone, gouda, or even parmesan for a different flavor profile.

→ Can I make this ahead of time?

You can prepare the sandwiches and refrigerate them uncooked for a short time. Reheat on a skillet when ready to serve for the best texture.

→ Is it possible to make this sandwich vegetarian?

Absolutely! Simply omit the pepperoni or use vegetarian alternatives available at many stores.

→ How can I keep the sandwiches from getting soggy?

Place finished sandwiches on a wire rack to cool slightly so they stay crispy and don’t collect steam underneath.

→ What can I serve with this dish?

Enjoy these sandwiches with a side of marinara sauce for dipping, a fresh salad, or crispy fries for a complete meal.